- 1. C.
正確。材料分別呈現空泛的善意與徒具形式的禮節。孔子的倫理須同時檢視關懷與行動,才不會兩頭落空。
Correct. One speaker lacks practiced responsibility, the other humane concern; Confucian evaluation cannot stop at either pole.
- 2. D.
正確組合。乙:批評的是缺乏倫理內容的表現,並非否定禮在行動中的訓練功能。丙:材料分別呈現空泛的善意與徒具形式的禮節。孔子的倫理須同時檢視關懷與行動,才不會兩頭落空。
Correct combination. B: The target is hollow observance, not the whole role of ritual in shaping relationships. C: One speaker lacks practiced responsibility, the other humane concern; Confucian evaluation cannot stop at either pole.
- 3. B.
正確。「端」表明可發展的起點。把第一次惻隱感受等同於成熟品德,便漏掉孟子的擴充要求。
Correct. The word sprout marks potential, not full possession of the virtue achieved through its development.
- 4. D.
正確組合。乙:「端」表明可發展的起點。把第一次惻隱感受等同於成熟品德,便漏掉孟子的擴充要求。丙:關鍵是區分「可能性」與「完成度」。考題若把二者畫上等號,便偷換孟子的命題。
Correct combination. B: The word sprout marks potential, not full possession of the virtue achieved through its development. C: A possibility claim is not an achievement claim; the distinction is testable in contextual reading.
- 5. B.
正確。政治理想可以影響制度發展,但材料要求另以史料評估實施情況。理念與成效屬於不同命題。
Correct. The historical influence of a program is not empirical evidence that its goals were fully implemented.
- 6. B.
正確組合。乙:將理念與落實區分,不是否定其思想史影響,反而能避免以口號代替歷史研究。丁:政治理想可以影響制度發展,但材料要求另以史料評估實施情況。理念與成效屬於不同命題。
Correct combination. B: Separating normative intent from historical outcomes enables rather than diminishes serious analysis. D: The historical influence of a program is not empirical evidence that its goals were fully implemented.
- 7. B.
正確。殷海光重視批判理性。材料不是否定所有政治理念,而是要求對任何權力主張保留論證空間。
Correct. His focus is on critical inquiry, not the automatic falsity of every political program.
- 8. B.
正確組合。乙:比較的重點是公共政治主張如何接受檢驗。不能把不同時代的主張當成同一段話。丙:殷海光重視批判理性。材料不是否定所有政治理念,而是要求對任何權力主張保留論證空間。
Correct combination. B: Shared relevance to politics does not eliminate differences in intellectual setting and argumentative aim. C: His focus is on critical inquiry, not the automatic falsity of every political program.
- 9. A.
正確。材料明示民主與科學的現代問題。把這層新的論證刪去,就無法理解現代新儒家的工作。
Correct. The modern institutional questions are part of the project; treating it as transcription erases that work.
- 10. D.
正確組合。甲:思想傳承不是語義不變。分清延續與重構才能理解學說之間的關係。乙:材料明示民主與科學的現代問題。把這層新的論證刪去,就無法理解現代新儒家的工作。
Correct combination. A: Transmission changes problems and claims, even where inherited terms remain recognizable. B: The modern institutional questions are part of the project; treating it as transcription erases that work.
- 11. A.
正確。同處新儒家脈絡不表示論證形式一致。材料已區分史學式批評與系統哲學的問題。
Correct. A shared intellectual milieu can contain different methods and political emphases.
- 12. A.
正確組合。乙:同處新儒家脈絡不表示論證形式一致。材料已區分史學式批評與系統哲學的問題。丙:材料一方重文獻與歷史,另一方重概念重構。有效比較須保留各自的證成方式。
Correct combination. B: A shared intellectual milieu can contain different methods and political emphases. C: A school label cannot do the evidentiary work of comparing distinct modes of argument.
- 13. B.
正確。史明的寫作將政治與社會鬥爭放進臺灣史。這不保證每一個判斷正確,卻提出必須辨認的解釋角度。
Correct. His political historiography reframes the questions asked, but its particular claims still require historical scrutiny.
- 14. D.
正確組合。乙:史明的寫作將政治與社會鬥爭放進臺灣史。這不保證每一個判斷正確,卻提出必須辨認的解釋角度。丙:可信的史學比較要能評價不同敘事如何選擇材料與提出因果解釋。
Correct combination. B: His political historiography reframes the questions asked, but its particular claims still require historical scrutiny. C: Interpretive significance and empirical corroboration are complementary tasks.
- 15. A.
正確。題幹的問題在「所有」與「完整」。只由一種典籍概括多種傳統,抹平了知識傳遞方式的差異。
Correct. The universal claim is unsupported: oral traditions and different epistemic settings cannot be assimilated to one canon.
- 16. B.
正確組合。乙:研究方法若先排除了口述經驗,便無法公平提出島嶼的多元思想問題。丁:題幹的問題在「所有」與「完整」。只由一種典籍概括多種傳統,抹平了知識傳遞方式的差異。
Correct combination. B: The method of selection determines whose intellectual traditions can even be represented. D: The universal claim is unsupported: oral traditions and different epistemic settings cannot be assimilated to one canon.
- 17. C.
正確。概念識別只是第一步。選項常用絕對化詞句改變原命題,逐字核對才能判斷推論是否過強。
Correct. An option can name the right tradition while making a false universal inference; qualifiers determine validity.
- 18. A.
正確組合。丙:概念識別只是第一步。選項常用絕對化詞句改變原命題,逐字核對才能判斷推論是否過強。丁:命題的範圍決定答案;若忽略前提,就容易選到過度延伸的敘述。
Correct combination. C: An option can name the right tradition while making a false universal inference; qualifiers determine validity. D: Tracking premises and scope is essential to distinguishing a supported conclusion from an overreach.
- 19. B.
正確。孔孟、朱熹與現代自由主義者處於不同語境。可比較概念,但不可將後人的解釋冒充先秦原話。
Correct. Comparative themes do not make later commentary or criticism a literal utterance of an earlier thinker.
- 20. C.
正確組合。丙:孔孟、朱熹與現代自由主義者處於不同語境。可比較概念,但不可將後人的解釋冒充先秦原話。丁:思想傳承的重點常在意義轉化。資料整理不能只比字形而忽略文本環境。
Correct combination. C: Comparative themes do not make later commentary or criticism a literal utterance of an earlier thinker. D: Continuity of words does not guarantee continuity of meaning or context.